Every year in the Republic of Kazakhstan, thousands of applications are submitted for government research and education grants, but only a limited number of them receive funding. Based on publicly available competition results and expert practice, more than 60–70% applications are rejected or returned even before the final review—often for reasons not directly related to the quality of the research idea.
For most applicants, the key problem lies not in a lack of scientific capacity, but in a lack of knowledge or a misinterpretation of the official evaluation criteria, which are strictly regulated by the laws and regulations of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Even a minor formal error or failure to meet the requirements can result in the automatic rejection of an application.
In this article, our experts conducted a strictly regulatory analysis of the current official documents of the Ministry of Science and Higher Education of the Republic of Kazakhstan governing the procedure for submitting and evaluating grant applications in 2025–2026. The analysis is based on the competition documentation, the rules for state scientific and technical review, and the practice of their application.
As a result, you'll learn:
What specific criteria do experts use to evaluate research and educational grants?;
At which stages are applications most often rejected;
which requirements are critical and which are secondary;
How to avoid common mistakes before you even submit your application.
This material will be useful to researchers, doctoral students, and project leaders who plan to participate in grant competitions in the Republic of Kazakhstan in the coming years.
1. Formal nonconformity of the bidding documents
The most common reason for dropouts.
What «ruins» an application:
— There are no required sections (abstract, explanatory note, calculations);
— Not all 3 languages (Kazakh / Russian / English) have been submitted;
— Word version ≠ system version is.ncste.kz;
— weak or superficial detail.
👉 Result:
The application is returned during the formal review stage—even without a substantive evaluation.
Don't want to have your application rejected because of minor technicalities?
Most grant projects in Kazakhstan are rejected even before they undergo expert evaluation—due to language issues, documentation, publications, or technical errors in the application.
We've put together a brief checklist that experts use to «scan» applications before approving them.
👇 Enter your information — and get a self-assessment checklist Before submitting the grant application.
Get a checklist before submitting your grant application
16 Critical Reasons Why Applications Are Most Often Returned or Rejected
This checklist will help you:
— review publications and journals before submission;
— avoid formal errors in documents;
— to determine whether a manager meets the criteria;
— reduce the risk of the application being automatically rejected.
2. Journal publications that do not count toward the total
An absolute killer. Zero chance.
What does this include:
— magazines from the list Scopus Discontinued Sources;
— magazines on HOLD / revaluation;
— journals that are formally included in Scopus / WoS, but are not recognized by the Committee on Culture, Sports, and Youth Affairs of the Ministry of National Education and Science of the Republic of Kazakhstan;
— journals with a high volume of complaints or «pseudo-indexing.».
Why this is fatal:
— such publications are, in effect, considered nonexistent;
— the research advisor automatically appears to be unqualified;
— The application is «rejected» even before the substantive review.
👉 Expert's verdict: «Competence not confirmed.».
3. The submissions do not meet the contest requirements
Formally, the articles exist—but in reality, they «don’t.».
Typical fatal outcomes:
— articles outside the permitted time frame;
— «the wrong database» (Scopus/WoS is required, but KOKSNVO was submitted—or vice versa);
— an insufficient number of publications;
— posts unrelated to the project.
Why this is critical:
— the manager does not meet the basic eligibility criteria;
— If an application doesn't «make the cut,» it's simply rejected.
👉 Expert's verdict: «Does not meet the contest requirements.».
4. Problems with the Research Advisor
If the leader «falls,» the entire project falls apart.
Key points:
— a manager listed in the Registry of Unscrupulous Experts;
— previous grants that were not fulfilled;
— an insufficient number of publications or «the wrong» publications;
— No academic degree;
— a non-resident of Kazakhstan (for core grants);
— exceeding the age limit (for «Zhas Galym»—over 40 years old).
👉 Result: Automatic rejection or return without a chance for revision.
5. Duplicate Project Topic
Experts pick up on this very quickly.
Common mistakes:
— the goals and objectives are nearly identical to those of a project that has already been funded;
— submitting two nearly identical applications in the same competition;
— There is no clear explanation of exactly what the scientific novelty is.
👉 Result: The application is withdrawn before a thorough review takes place.
6. Required documents are missing
Without documents, no one can «figure anything out.».
The following are most commonly missing:
— a current certificate of accreditation for the organization;
— the opinion of the bioethics committee (for biomedical research);
— contract and confirmation of co-funding (for applied projects).
👉 Result: Automatic return of the application.
7. Violation of Participation and Co-financing Limits
A technical—but very strict—reason.
Critical violations:
— The project lead is listed on 2 or more projects;
— Team member — in 3 or more projects;
— co-funding <1% (for applied research);
— «partner» — a branch or affiliated entity without an actual contract.
👉 Result: All «excess» applications will be returned without review.
Conclusions
An analysis of the official evaluation criteria shows that the grant funding system in the Republic of Kazakhstan is significantly more formalized than applicants often assume. A research idea—even a strong and relevant one—cannot compensate for violations of the basic requirements of the competition guidelines, problems with the publication record, or the ineligibility of the principal investigator.
A key factor for success remains the proper demonstration of scientific competence—primarily through publications, which must not merely exist «on paper» but must also meet the requirements of a specific competition, field, and regulatory bodies. Publications in unrecognized journals or errors in their documentation effectively devalue the entire project, regardless of its content.
Formal procedures play an equally important role. A significant portion of applications is screened out even before the expert evaluation due to technical and organizational shortcomings—ranging from language requirements to inconsistencies in the submitted versions of documents. This suggests that preparing a grant application should be viewed not as a purely scientific task, but as a comprehensive process that combines scientific, administrative, and regulatory components.
Ultimately, successfully participating in grant competitions in Kazakhstan requires not only scientific expertise but also a deep understanding of the «rules of the game» as set forth in official documents. It is precisely a systematic approach to preparing an application—from verifying publications to the final check for compliance with requirements—that significantly increases the chances of passing all stages of the selection process.
If your weak point is publications, journals, or documents, don't risk applying.
Just one «inappropriate» post or a minor technicality could cause the project to be rejected even before it goes through the review process.
We are in Academy of Articles We step in to eliminate common risks: we review the publication section, provide guidance on structure and requirements, and ensure the materials are properly formatted for submission.
Grant Case Study (Science Foundation): https://a-articles.kz/kejs-klienta-fon-nauki/
Do you want to let go of all that control and move forward without chaos? Please contact us, and we'll find a solution tailored to your situation.



